Scale invaders and the ascent of pessimism
Laura Ruetsche (University of Michigan)
Abstract: 21st century philosophy of physics has been enriched by a developing alliance between (i) a broad effective field theory philosophy, embracing a range of effective field theory techniques, and (ii) a species of scientific realism educated by that philosophy and those techniques. Key to the alliance is the idea that, for a healthy variety of quantum field theories understood as effective theories, a separation of scales enables the aspirant realist to identify "the right variables" for effective physics, and frame her realism in their terms. In this talk, I'll explicate the alliance between physicists' effective theory technologies and philosophers'—specifically, scientific realists'—aspirations to understand our best physics as revealing deep truths about the physical world. Then I'll develop a challenge to the alliance in the form of what I call scale invaders—something, I'll argue, working physicists should be hoping for, despite the trouble they make for scientific realism.
HEP - theoryhistory and philosophy of physicsquantum physics
Audience: advanced learners
( video )
Tricontinental Quantum Fundamentals Seminar
Series comments: The Tricontinental Quantum Fundamentals Seminar (3C-QFS) was an online seminar series connecting researchers from Australia, Europe, and America. Its goal was to bring together those working on foundational topics in relativistic quantum physics and facilitate discussion between the three continents.
The seminar series has been on indefinite hiatus since late 2026.
An archive of past talks is hosted on the 3C-QFS YouTube channel.
| Organizers: | Evan Gale*, Nicholas Funai, Germain Tobar* |
| *contact for this listing |
